Sept. 30, 2024 - In a recent ruling, Canada’s Federal Court of Appeal held that Facebook, Inc. (now Meta Platforms Inc.) breached its obligations under Canada's Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA) by sharing Facebook users’ personal information with third-party apps hosted...
Matt Milne-Smith Speaks to Lexpert on Slowdown in Securities Class Actions
In an article published in the Lexpert Special Edition – Canada’s Leading Litigation Lawyers, Davies partner Matt Milne-Smith discusses the impact of the Supreme Court of Canada’s 2015 trilogy of decisions interpreting the leave standard for secondary market securities class action filings in Canada.
“One plaintiff’s lawyer I was facing called it nothing but a speed bump,” Matt says. “But it was a speed bump that wrecked his case.”
Matt believes that the Supreme Court’s decision has properly recognized the inherent challenges and complexities that underlie public company disclosure. “What they’ve come to see is that what might appear to be a straightforward case of misrepresentation can turn out to be a complex case of business executives exercising their best judgment in trying circumstances,” he explains. “Sometimes they’ll get it right and sometimes they’ll get it wrong, but our courts have recognized that merely getting it wrong doesn’t merit a multi-million-dollar class action based on tortious conduct.”
The good news for the business community is that Ontario’s secondary market liability regime contains meaningful protections for issuers. “There was a perception for some period of time before and after the enactment of the legislation that securities class actions might be low-hanging fruit for plaintiffs’ lawyers,” Matt says. “Practice has proven that this is not in fact the case.”
Related
Better Late Than Never? Not So for Directors’ and Officers’ Liability Coverage
Aug. 29, 2024 - Directors and officers facing liability claims, including investigations and enforcement proceedings, must pay careful attention to the notice provisions of their directors’ and officers’ (D&O) liability coverage policies and ensure that they report claims to their insurer in a timely manner. As...